What About Your Math High Achievers?

You know those students — the ones who finish before you’ve even finished passing out the papers?
That was my second-grade class.

They zipped through every math assignment.
Not only quickly — but correctly.

And me? I was a brand-new teacher with no idea what to do with them.
So… they waited. 😬

They were polite. Patient.
And completely bored.

---

The Problem: Too Many Levels, Too Little Time

Like so many classrooms, mine was filled with every level of learner.
I knew my strugglers needed extra time and attention.

But my high achievers?
I was told, “Don’t worry. They’ll learn anyway. Focus on your needy kids.”

Have you ever been told that?
If so, you know how wrong it feels.

Because they have needs, too.
Just… different ones.

---

The Guilt (and the Spark)

I’ll be honest — it didn’t feel right.
I could see those quick learners waiting, day after day.

And even though I was overwhelmed by the thought of differentiating again,
I wanted more for them.

So I began creating.

I needed activities that would:
✅ Strengthen problem-solving and reasoning
✅ Keep previously learned skills sharp
✅ Build math vocabulary and communication
✅ Encourage independent and collaborative thinking

I wanted math that stretched their brains without giving me hours of prep.

---

Why It Matters

Students who “get math” still need depth, challenge, and joy in what they’re doing. When we give them open-ended opportunities and a little extra rigor, they soar.

And best of all?
Their excitement is contagious. 🌟

That’s when I knew I needed a steady stash of ready-to-go math challenges that my early finishers would love.

---

The Solution: Algebra Before Algebra!

Here’s one of my favorites — and my students LOVED it.

It’s a simple twist that introduces algebraic thinking in a super approachable way.

Start with this on your whiteboard:
A + A = 4

Then ask,
👉 “If A is a number, what would it have to be?”

When students figure out that A = 2, you’ll see those lightbulbs flicker! 💡

Continue with:

• A + 7 = 10

• B – 4 = 5

• Mix in addition and subtraction

• Eventually, try double-digit problems for your advanced thinkers

---

Let Them Struggle (Productively!)

I quickly learned that it’s a good thing to let students struggle a little.
Don’t rush in with the answer — let them reach for it!

Encourage them to talk with one another, share ideas, and explain their thinking.
That back-and-forth conversation helps them deepen their understanding far more than being “told” the answer ever could.

If you sense frustration, step in with a gentle nudge —
something like,
💬 “What could A be if it’s smaller than 5?” or
💬 “Try substituting a number you think works and see what happens.”

These small hints guide them without taking away the satisfaction of solving it themselves.
You’ll love hearing the reasoning that comes from these discussions!

---

Step It Up

Once your students understand, move into two-digit problems like this:

You know the real problem is 72 – 10 = 62.
But for your students, write:
72 – AB = 62

Now they must find:
A = ___ B = ___

Each letter stands for a different digit.
For example:
58 – 33 = 25 → becomes 58 – AA = 25 → A = 3.

They’ll love the challenge, and you’ll love watching them reason through it.

---

Extend the Challenge

🎯 Have students create their own problems!
Write them on index cards, sign their names, and share them with the class.

You can:

• Hang the cards on a ring at your early finisher station

• Use them for morning work

• Or set up a Math Challenge Center

Before long, your students will be building the challenges for each other!
Talk about engagement — and no extra prep for you. 🙌

---

Want Ready-to-Go Challenges?

If you love this idea but need a little head start, I’ve created a resource just for you.
It includes:

• 20 print + digital pages

• 57 ready-to-use math challenges

• Step-by-step examples

• Two fun characters who keep students smiling and motivated

Perfect for Grades 1–3 and designed to stretch your math high achievers in meaningful ways.

✨ Try the free version by subscribing below — it’s the perfect way to get started nurturing your young mathematicians!

---

❤️ You’ll Love Watching Them Think Differently

Once your students get started, you’ll see their excitement grow — and maybe even catch yourself smiling as they teach each other new strategies.

That’s when you know you’ve found the magic balance: every student challenged, engaged, and loving math.

---

Grab your free early finisher math challenges below and see the difference they make!

 

Let me know how the tasks work for you. Share any tips or suggestions you have in the comments below. I’d love to hear your math early finisher tips.

✏️ Loved these ideas for your gifted learners? 💡

You might also enjoy these posts packed with classroom-tested tips and ready-to-use math ideas:

👉 Quick & Engaging Math Code Problems Every Teacher Needs in Their Toolbox

👉 Quick Math Early Finisher Activities for Anytime Learning

👉 Engage Every Learner with Math Scavenger Hunts – No-Prep, Self-Checking, and Fun!

Thanks!

And as always,